“Awe: we need awe to love people, to look up to our heroes, to change the world. And awe is now under attack – it’s being replaced by indifference, stupor, blind tolerance.”
I read in Doctor Who magazine that Russell T. Davies was born by ceaserian section – he was his mother’s third c-section and in those days (1963) you weren’t allowed to have more than two, apparently. I can’t help but wonder what might have happened if Russell had to have been born naturally and had died…what a loss to the world.
The second series has improved on the first in one aspect at least – the crew seem to have a better idea of suspense. For example in the first series, the story that reintroduced the Daleks was imaginatively called ‘Dalek’. Having said that, the first series was so raw and fresh that it could cut your face off, these minor imperfections added to the edginess of the whole production. In retrospect I think a lot of that clarity was down to the ‘damaged goods’ characterisation of the 9th Doctor. He’s so rough and sharp at the same time you feel terrified for him and for the people around him. A good part of the series arc was watching the Doctor’s character change and evolve as he regained his humanity. Would the Doctor of ‘Rose’ have been more able to press the red buttion and destroy the Daleks than the Doctor of ‘Parting of the Ways’? Maybe.
However, the Doctor was less reliant on Rose to save the day this time around. The tenth Doctor seems just that little bit more resourceful and able to help himself.
For me, the series high points were: Most of Tooth and Claw (it was a pleasant surprise after what Rusty usually dishes up, with the exception of Boomtown), all of Girl in the Fireplace, The Impossible Planet (but not the Satan Pit) and Fear Her. The big dip in the series was Love and Monsters, but I liked the fact that it was different, even though it wasn’t especially good-different.
I finally pinned down what it was about the second series that annoyed me. It’s the fact that some of the stories are actully better (better pace, better ideas), but they seem to be playing them down and making them mundane instead of showing all that vibrancy that the series deserves. And also the Doctor/Rose thing bugs the hell out of me. You just feel like such a ruddy gooseberry while they run around giving each other the goo goo eyes (the Doctor not so much). That pair are so smug together you want to punch the bejesus out of them (or just Rose).
I’m fine with emotion (I mean, I watch Hollyoaks…). But not when it has all the impact of a giant meaty fist ramming itself down your throat and pulling your internal organs out one by one. Especially when the afoementioned fist has been shoved up Russell T. Davies massive smug derierre five minutes previously.
We were given no character arc (at least not yet) for the tenth Doctor – we just had to sit there for thirteen episodes and watch as he pandered to Rose and laughed at her jokes. Sometimes we caught a glimpse of what was beneath the surface (most notably in Girl in the Fireplace and in other sequences where Rose was off doing something else and the Doctor was left on his own). We have lost the team factor that made nine and Rose’s relationship so electric. In this series, Rose seems to think that the Doctor is her boyfriend and some great stories (Fear Her, School reunion) are spoilt by Rose’s behavior and her and the Doctor’s smugness. Although, looking at the season as a whole story, this fact means something. It is used to accentuate the fact that the Doctor and Rose have got too close to each other and Rose thinking it can never change. She actually tells the Doctor that she will stay with him for ever, and is determined to stay with him and help him no matter what. Watching the whole series again as one huge story, knowing exactly what happens in Doomsday, I get the feeling that their separation is inevitable. I have heard it said that the ending of a good novel is believable and inevitable. Maybe Rusty has done something right.
Another thing I’ve been wondering about is that everyone was saying how awful series one was last year, and yet now series two has been and gone, people are saying how great series one was. Maybe this time next year we’ll be saying the same about series 2? Maybe that’s the plan? To steadily make the series’s worse as each year goes by until eventuallly the Doctor is living in a council flat with Rose, Martha and Sarah Jane and their 16 children. The Doctor works in a sandwich factory and the series has a…(wait for it….)…laughter track. All kinds of alien invasion fun and wacky high jinks ensue, including the amazing alien that can fart, burp and do a poo all at the same time, and looks like a yellow sausage, while weilding a steak knife at the regulars.
What I like about this series and its themes (while we’re on the subject, because I’m going to go off on one of my bizarre theories in a minute) is that the Doctor and Rose have actually caused their own downfall. It is their irresponsible behavior that causes Queen Vic to create Torchwood to track him throughout the centuries, and it is Torchwood that finally separates them. That idea could also tie in to the fact that The Doctor and Rose seem to be having way too much of a good time galvanting around the universe, not seeming to care who dies along the way as long as it isn’t them.
Having said that, there isn’t as much symbolism in the second series. There was so much you coud read into the first series – Norse mythology, Christian mytholgy, the big stuff – and compared to that the second series is so shallow. It just reads like a second rate love story, maybe the Titanic or something.
I noticed a lot of recurring themes in this series, desptite the lack of mythic symbolism – the image of a moon cropped up in the first three episode of the series, as follows:
New Earth: There is a cresent moon on the side of the hospital building
Tooth and Claw: Moonlight plays an important part in the proceedings.
School Reunion: We see the bat creatures flying past a huge full moon.
A lot of the stories also seem to have a long sequence set at night – Age of Steel, Girl In The Fireplace, Love and Monsters, School Reunion, Tooth and Claw, Satan Pit is very dark anyway. I only just noticed that one.
Yet another running theme is of people or creatures being a long way from home.
New Earth: The Doctor mentions that they will be travelling ‘Further than we have ever gone before.’
Tooth and Claw: The werewolf boy mentions being “So far away from home.” Queen Victoria makes the supposedly flyaway comment that the world of werewolves and ghosts is ‘Not my world’ (a hint of where Rose will end up at the end of the series?).
School Reunioun: Nothing that stands out.
Girl InThe Fireplace: The Doctor says to Mickey: “You’re a long way from home, Mickey.” about the Diagma (?) cluster being two galaxies away from Earth.
Age of Cybermen: The Doctor, Rose and Mickey enter a parallel universe. How far away from home can you get?
Idiot’s Lantern: The wire had been exiled from it’s home planet.
Impossible Satan Pit: The people livign on the planet are so far away from their home, Earth. And living on the edge of a black hole. The Beast mentions being ‘From before the beginning of time’.
Love and Monsters: Can’t think of anything.
Fear Her: The creatrure that possesses Chloe is a long way from it’s family and home and it’s terrified.
Army of Doomsday: The Cybermen, Jake, Mickey and Pete come from the parallel universe. Rose and Jackie go back there at the end. I think this theme means that Rose will end up being as far away from home as it possible to get – she has to live out her life in another universe, parallel to her original universe, but not the same.
What is Doctor supposed to be sorry for? I think the Doctor or someone else says the line “I’m sorry. I’m so sorry.” in every episode of this series. Maybe its supposed to mean that everybody is sorry for something? (see below)
It’s bizarre that we have all these great themes and some of them actually mean something (there’s a whole section on the Impossible Planet/SatanPit symbolism in Wikipedia) yet the stories themselves are so superficial they are almost cartoon like. It’s an interesting concept though. You could have a series about the characters doing nothing at all but shagging each other and watching the telly, but you could put all these little symbolic themes and bits in it and people would call it a post modern masterpiece or something.
Parallels between series 1/27 and series 2/28:
In The Satan Pit, when Jefferson is trapped on the wrong end of the tunnel he says “I’m sorry. I was a bit slow.” which is the same thing that Rose says when she becomes trapped in Dalek. Also in the Satan Pit Rose screams at Zach and Danny to “Take me back!” when they are forcing her to leave the Doctor. She said this in Parting Of The Ways when the TARDIS returns her to her time against her will.
In Bad Wolf the Doctor says “I haven’t got a plan, and doesn’t that just scare you to death?” Rose says a similar thing in Doomsday: “5 million Cybermen? Easy! One Doctor? Now you’re scared.” I know that isn’t exactly parallel, but it is very similer. It could be emphasing the fact that Rose has become like the Doctor in a lot of ways, picking up his mannerisms and reacting like he might do. Jackie says something to this effect in Army Of Ghosts: “Look at you. You even look like him!”
I’ve worked out what the Doctor is sorry for! This is all his fault! Hahaha!! HA! After all, it’s his fault that Torchwood was created. (see above)
The difference between the 9th and 10th Doctors is as great as you can get without having to go to another planet. The ninth was a brooding old war horse trying to come to terms with the destruction of his people and he was afraid to let anyone get too close to him for fear of them being destroyed too. We, as viewers, were given the pleasue of watching his shell gradually disppear until he was finally ‘doing domestic’ and having a laugh with his new ‘adopted’ family – Rose, Mickey and Cap’n Jack in Boomtwon. That episode showed how good the group could be as a team, even though Jack was given a back bench for the majority of the story. In a sense the ninth Doctor was always doomed, and it was the development of his charachter that assisted in his death in the end. Lacking the heartlessless to kill the Daleks indirectly caused his regeneration.
The tenth doctor is too much fun. He’s quirky, he’s zany. He quotes Kylie Minogue and watches Eastenders. He’s not as engaging because of this. The ninth Doctor had this wonderful magnetic aura of brooding mystery, which this one doesn’t possess. I think that if less of an attempt was made to make him all cool and likable in the manner if a fluffy kitten, he could be really good. Make him more quietly menacing, and eccentric (but more in the style of eating marmalade with his fingers, as opposed to being the Doctor who runs around wearing a nappy and giggling a lot. We don’t need that sort of eccentric). I think Tennant would take to that quite well. Leave off the ‘look at me I’m all wacky and fabulous. I’m like one of the guys out of your favourite band!” stuff for a bit. It’s a bit wearing. Make him more subtle and interesting and we’ll get along just fine.
With Eccleston, he cold just walk into a room and you leapt to the edge of your seat. When Tennant comes into a room you think “What silly thing is he going say this time?” Well, this is the guy who thinks it would be the epitome of coolness to go up to a guy called Alonzo and say “Alonzay, Alonzo!” I rest my case. Damn it was heavy!
I think with this series there was too much resting on it’s shoulders. The first series series had its bad points, sure, but they seemed to fade into the distance this year. The simple fact is that it could never live up to the legacy that season 1 (and Christopher Eccleston) left in its wake. Will David Tennant regenerate standing up? Doubtful.
It’s like that difficult second album that everybody goes out and buys because the first album was MINT and then mostly everyone ends up feeling vaugely disappointed and empty. And cold. So cold. That’s what this series of Doctor Who does to you – it leaves you cold and yearning for the good old days, when the Doctor wore a leather jacket and Rose was still in possesion of her character (it made a brief appearance in Girl in the Fireplace, but has not been seen since. I have appealed to the missing persons bureau, but it is likely that Rose’s character will soon be pronounced as officially dead.). We all hoped that it would expand on the first series’s greatness and become something all of its own at the same time. We all looked forward to it too much. I no longer have any hopes of greatness for the third series. It might be better that way. I suppose we’ll all be sorry in 7 years time when the last ever episode has just aired after nine series and it is revealed that it was all one bloody long symbolic story to end all stories, and all this shit from series 2 falls beautifully into place. Mind you, it’s all very well, having a pretty forest but what good does that do you, when every tree is slowly going rotton on the inside? I have heard someone else describe the first series as being like a Marianne Faithful album and the second being like an album of Westlife cover versions. I have never heard a song by Marianne Faithful so couldn’t possibly comment…(Kudos, Tom!)
On the whole, I think the stories improved, especially the pacing and Russell’s skill in storytelling. Stephen Moffat was forced to take only one episode this time (seriously we could have lost Love and Monsters. Tell the Blue Peter kid the budget won’t stretch to yet ANOTHER green fat costume), and Mark Gatiss’s tale didn’t live up to expectations. Or maybe that was just because we know the formulae he uses by now.
The characterisation went down the bog, except in the case of Mickey Mick Mick Mickey (everybody go ‘wooo!’) who improved in leaps and bounds. I suppose it was quite nice to see Pete again and build on his characer,but it got a bit much in the end. The character of the Doctor seemed too lightweight and undecided. He shouted, or he was fun, or he was introspective, or he was quirky. There was no actual character in there. I won’t even mention Rose (again).
My final word is that I would shag David Tennant, but Christopher Eccleston is, and always will be, MY Doctor (fucke you, Rose, I got there first.) It’s not about the shagability – it’s in the performance and the character and frankly at the moment, the tenth Doctor’s characterisation is shit.
Watch the first series again. All of it. It’s fantastic. Absolutely Fantastic!
Posted in Reviews